The Iceberg Project Mandarin

Follow Cher as she learns Mandarin

  • Blog
  • About the Project
    • Meet the Team
    • About Cher
  • Get in Touch
  • Language Tools

Should you learn Zhuyin (Bopomofo) or Pinyin for learning Chinese pronunciation?

Should you learn Zhuyin (Bopomofo) or Pinyin for learning Chinese pronunciation?

If you haven’t heard of Zhuyin (Bopomofo) yet, it’s a system used for teaching Chinese pronunciation to children before they are able to read and recognize the torrents of characters that will be in their future.

It uses a symbol plus a tone mark like this:

Character: 漂亮

Pronunciation: ㄆㄧㄠˋ ㄌㄧㄤˋ

These symbols are placed vertically descending next to the character like this:

If you just started learning Mandarin on your own, it’s likely that you haven’t run into this system yet. Most likely, you’ve learned the Romanization system called pinyin.

In fact, almost all learners of Chinese use pinyin to learn pronunciation.

When I first started learning Chinese, I learned pinyin, too, and when I learned that zhuyin existed half a decade later, I jumped at the chance to learn it because I felt like it was the Chinese alphabet that I had been waiting for.

(It’s probably not fair to say I jumped at the chance…more like I meekly walked toward it.)

As I explored these new sounds, I recognized how vastly different they sounded to the pinyin sounds I had been taught (and had been incorrectly pronouncing).

They felt & sounded more accurate.

The pinyin that I had been taught over a period of two classes, for less than 90 minutes without long-term repetition or feedback, were surprisingly inadequate to what I was learning now.

From my own experience I think that you can absolutely learn pinyin & pronounce Chinese correctly (in fact, students from all over China learn pinyin for pronunciation), but you have to learn pinyin well.

The truth is that our idea of what the words should sound like based on our understanding of English monster truck blocks our way to ever pronouncing it correctly.

Bopomofo makes sure that we can’t associate the sounds we see on paper with the sounds we have in English from the start.

I also think it gives us a better chance to learn pronunciation more accurately, thus saving us pocketfuls of anxiety & embarrassment down the road.

Plus, Bopomofo, to me, feels more authentic…which can be great, except that it isn’t always easy to find learning materials that use it.

Many materials rely on pinyin to represent the sounds, and this can be a barrier because some of the best learning materials, like Assimil, will only use pinyin and characters.

All in all, learn both.

Learning both gives you a better chance to gain clear pronunciation and offers a variety of resources for you to continue practicing.

If you really want to choose just one I recommend starting with pinyin because you’ll have more access to materials and it will feel like a more natural transition.

However, if you do choose pinyin, I recommend that you watch this video series to make sure you’re pronouncing the sounds as correctly as you can.

[VIDEO] Comprehensive Pinyin Review (Part 1) – Yangyang Cheng

Which system do you prefer? Tell me what you’re thinking in the comments below.

Avatar

About Cher

Cher is the founder of The Iceberg Project and a passionate learner of the Italian, Mandarin and Spanish languages. In a little town called Vegas, you can find her searching the Internet for Doctor Who and Parks & Rec memes, drinking bubble tea, or talking about how much she loves grammar.

« 7 Resources for Learning and Practicing Tones in Mandarin Chinese
Mandarin Chinese Word Speed Dates: 才 (cái) »

Trackbacks

  1. Should you learn Mandarin from Taiwan or China? (& What are the differences?) says:
    July 13, 2015 at 8:52 am

    […] Which one is better? Check out this article: Should you learn Zhuyin (Bopomofo) or Pinyin for learning Chinese pronunciation? […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Having a hard time learning Chinese? (Yep, we all are. Join the club.)
Sign up for free weekly notes of encouragement, tips, and lessons by email

Recent Posts

  • 5 People Who Do Chinese Online Better Than Anyone Else
  • 10 Must-Watch Taiwanese Dramas for Chinese Learners
  • How to Start Learning Radicals in Chinese
  • Day 90 Update: Learning Mandarin Chinese with the #Add1Challenge
  • How to Give Compliments in Mandarin Chinese

© 2021 · Powered by Genesis Framework & Love for Italy · Design by: Bellano Web Studio

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok